Communities of Dialogue Russian and Ukrainian Émigrés in Modernist Prague

Repository | Journal | Volume | Article

238369

Melancholic epistemology

George Graham

pp. 399-422

Abstract

Too little attention has been paid by philosophers to the cognitive and epistemic dimensions of emotional disturbances such as depression, grief, and anxiety and to the possibility of justification or warrant for such conditions. The chief aim of the present paper is to help to remedy that deficiency with respect to depression. Taxonomy of depression reveals two distinct forms: depression (1) with intentionality and (2) without intentionality. Depression with intentionality can be justified or unjustified, warranted or unwarranted. I argue that the effort of Aaron Beck to show that depressive reasoning is necessarily illogical and distorted is flawed. I identify an essential characteristic of that depression which is a mental illness. Finally, I describe the potential of depression to provide credal contact with important truths.

Publication details

Published in:

(1990) Synthese 82 (3).

Pages: 399-422

DOI: 10.1007/BF00413883

Full citation:

Graham George (1990) „Melancholic epistemology“. Synthese 82 (3), 399–422.